Gay Surprise Men, Man Surprise Cock - CockFilledMen.com

Updated: November 22nd, 2025

Anal Surprise

anal 1:13
Muscular Stud Serviced by Blonde Slut

couples 5:03
Broke Straight Boys - Denver Grand and Conner

straight boys 2:31
Broke Straight Boys - Ricky

straight boys 2:31
Super Hard Bareback

bareback, anal, hardcore 7:04
Lick His Ass then Fuck it

couples 2:00
Straight Boy Jan Gets Gay

hunks 5:00
Twinks Fucking

couples 2:45
Broke Straight Boys - Ricky

straight boys 5:01
Muscular Stud Serviced by Blonde Slut

couples 5:03
Turkish Cum Bath

big cock 5:02
Jock Fuckers

amateur 1:03
Little Gay Anniversary

hardcore 5:03
Caught By Surprise

voyeur 1:43
Caught By Surprise

amateur 9:51
Bent Over Couch, Straight Ass Fucked

jocks 4:24
Voyeurs Dream

blowjobs, jocks, straight boys :40
Hot Big Dick

hardcore 1:08
Twink Double Fucked

twinks 1:30
Sucking That Hot Latino Cock

outdoor 5:01
Hot Latino Stripper Max

hunks 2:00
caughtbysurprise_1

jocks 1:02
caughtbysurprise_4

jocks 1:09
He Fucking Delivery Latino Lad

jocks 1:04
Alexsander Freitas and Danny Brooks

hunks 4:58
Broke Straight Boys - Denver Grand and Conner

straight boys 2:31
Broke Straight Boys - Ricky

straight boys 2:31
Latino Daddy Stroking His Dick

small dicks 4:55
Fratboy Fucks to Join Club

jocks 4:24
Spit Roasting the Stripper

hunks 5:03
Hole Surprise

blowjobs, masturbation, straight boys 4:15
What a Surprise

blowjobs, masturbation, cumshot 4:07
21 yo Sexy Hottie

blowjobs 3:15
Broke Straight Boys - Aj And Ben 2

straight boys 5:57
sticky surprise

amateur, masturbation, cumshot 1:31
Latino Daddy Stroking His Dick

amateur, cumshot, masturbation, small dicks 4:55
caughtbysurprise_1

jocks 1:02
Straight Rent Boys - Mitchs Cock Sucking Lesson

masturbation, straight boys, big cock 2:29
Cock Surprise

blowjobs, masturbation, straight boys 4:00
Huge Cock In Tiny Mouth

interracial, blowjobs, big cock 4:07
Hairy Bear Wanks Short Dick

amateur, masturbation, bears, hairy 3:44
Cocky Tip

voyeur 2:22
Latin Boys

twinks 1:17
Snap Shot

muscle 1:13
Caught By Surprise

amateur 9:51
Straight guy thinks he is sucked

gotsurprise, ungloryhole, cock, amateur, blowjob, straight, gloryhole, surprise, tricked, gaysex, gayporn, suck, bj, gay-blowjob, penis-sucking 6:07
Bound Twink Gets Teased and Toyed

hairy 2:54
Turkish Cum Bath

big cock 5:02
Tristan Jaxx has been seeing Patrick Kennedy

hunks 4:58
Outdoor Suck Training

twinks 2:59
aughtbysurprise_3

jocks 1:09
Cameron Adams and Phenix Saint

amateur 1:23
Hot Latino Stripper Max

hunks 2:00
Asian Rimming His Wet Raunchy Ass

asslicking 2:21
Sexy Cock Gets Sucked Hard

hunks 1:10
Spit Roasting the Stripper

hunks 5:03
hunks hook up in the afternoon

hunks 1:54
Broke Straight Boys - Tomas

straight boys 2:31
Voyeurs Dream

straight boys :40
Three Way Anal

cumshot, anal, cum eating 40:06
Office Stiff Cocks Cumming

anal, blowjobs, group, hunks, muscle 6:15
Raw Latino Bareback Ass Fucking

anal, bareback, couples, latino 1:25
GayRoom Big cock Kyler give a sleep creep surprise

anal, blowjobs, cumshot 6:06
ughtbysurprise_2

jocks 1:04
Sexual Therapy For Robbie Anthony

blowjobs, hardcore, jocks, masturbation, twinks 5:04
Sexual Therapy For Robbie Anthony

amateur, anal, hardcore, hunks, jocks 4:58
Broke Straight Boys - Denver Grand and Conner

anal, straight boys, twinks 2:31
Pacos Monsterous Cock

blowjobs, fucking machines, cumshot, big cock, stripping 1:30
Full surprised handjob

amateur, twinks, masturbation 9:27
The Intern

amateur, bareback, twinks, asian 1:01
Teacher Gets Some Twink Ass!

blowjobs, anal, big cock 4:56
Ass teasing cowboy jacks off

amateur, toys, masturbation, dildo, object insertion 1:07
Cum Rain Gay Facial Hot Bareback Fuck

bareback, blowjobs, facials, masturbation, cumshot, anal, hardcore 3:00
Cream Pie Surprise

bareback, blowjobs, masturbation, anal, group, hardcore 2:00
Surprise At The Gloryhole

twinks, blowjobs, group 18:50
Fleshlight In Shower

toys, masturbation, big cock 5:16
Straight Guy Surprised He Likes It

blowjobs, straight boys, hunks 3:00
Surprise Sex Party

group 21:33
Boys Barebacking

twinks 1:25
Wrestling

hardcore 1:12
Golden Gate Solos

hunks 2:09
Caught By Surprise

hunks 1:00
Anal Surprise

anal 1:13
Anal Surprise

object insertion 6:15
Str8 sportsbar pickup 'better than pussy

straight, str8, stud, hung, blond, big cock, blowjob, college, first time, slender, oral, seduction 6:04
Soccer Bubble Butt

amateur :59
Raw Latino Bareback Ass Fucking

couples 1:25
Amateur Cock Making Cum Fly Everywhere

small dicks 1:57
Broke Straight Boys - Ricky

straight boys 5:01
Aj And Ben 2

straight boys 5:57
Surprise Fuck

amateur, bareback, jocks, blowjobs, anal, hardcore 11:01
Black Express Package

blacks, masturbation, big cock 5:02
Morning Surprise

masturbation 6:16
Ari Sylvio and Girth Brooks

amateur 1:09
Muscular Stud Serviced by Blonde Slut

hunks 5:03
Two Gay Strangers Fuck And Cum Hard

cumshot 7:00
super loaded Crazy Facial Cum

bareback 3:05
Broke Straight Boys - Denver Grand and Conner

straight boys 5:00
Jock Fuckers

amateur 1:03
Shaven Headed Bobby

amateur, anal, cum eating 5:57
Gloryhole Cock Toyed with a Brush

amateur, cumshot, masturbation, toys 4:02
Amateur Makes An Afternoon Snack

amateur, cum eating, cumshot, facials, masturbation :54
Straight Boy Jan Gets Gay

anal, hunks, straight boys 5:00
Twinks Fucking

anal, couples, twinks 2:45
Two Gay Strangers Fuck And Cum Hard

anal, blowjobs, cumshot 7:00
18 year old wrestler gets surprise handjob

amateur, jocks, masturbation, straight boys 1:17
Bear Public Beach Wankoff

amateur, masturbation, outdoor 4:01
Tristan Hollister And Carlos

anal, big cock, facials, twinks 5:02
Swallow Gay Dick Bareback Scene

bareback, big cock, cumshot, pornstars 3:00
Broke Straight Boys - Tomas

straight boys, masturbation, blacks, big cock 2:31
Alexsander Freitas and Danny Brooks

anal, big cock, hunks 4:58
Tristan Jaxx has been seeing Patrick Kennedy

anal, hunks, jocks 4:58
Broke Straight Boys - Ricky

masturbation, straight boys, twinks 2:31
Jock Fuckers

amateur, anal, group 1:03
Rodd And Jamie Blowin Loads

jocks, fucking machines, cumshot, stripping 1:30
Old Memories, New Moves

bareback, blowjobs, anal, latino, stripping 5:00
Johnny First time sucking a hard cock

twinks, blowjobs, masturbation, straight boys, cum eating 5:01
Aj And Ben 2

couples, masturbation, straight boys 5:57
Cream Pie Surprise #04

bareback, hunks, hairy 1:00
A Little Gay Anniversary

twinks, blowjobs, anal, hunks 4:51
Paulie Cums Over

blowjobs, masturbation, fucking machines, cumshot, big cock 1:30
Underwear Robbing Perverts

muscle, blowjobs, anal, bdsm 8:09
Arabian Fantasy Threesome

blowjobs, fucking machines, anal, group, big cock 1:30
Gils Birthday Tickle Party

blowjobs, feet, stripping, asian, small dicks 1:41
Str8 virgin ass penetrated for the first time

amateur, blowjobs, anal, straight boys 1:19
Mason and Jake 3

blowjobs, masturbation, pornstars 2:00
Noahs Massage and Handjob

amateur, muscle, cumshot, straight boys, hairy 1:10
Hard Gay Bareback Fuck Cumshot

blowjobs, facials, cumshot, anal, hardcore 6:58
Jason Martin And Bobby Long

bareback, masturbation, anal, hardcore 1:00
Hot Threesome On The Couch

blowjobs, masturbation, group 4:04
Bareback Cumshot Anal Fuck

bareback, blowjobs, facials, masturbation, cumshot, anal, hardcore 5:00
A Little Gay Anniversary Surprise

bareback, blowjobs, masturbation, anal, hardcore 5:04
Spit Roasting The Stripper!

bareback, blowjobs, masturbation, anal, group, hardcore 5:04
Deep Throat Dick Suck And Gay Fuck

bareback, blowjobs, facials, masturbation, cumshot, anal, hardcore 6:57
Gay Couple Shows How To Fuck Right

bareback, blowjobs, cumshot, anal, hardcore 6:58
James and Csaba

bareback, asslicking, jocks, masturbation, anal, hardcore 2:05
Creampie Surprise

bareback, interracial, masturbation, anal, hardcore 2:00
Creampie Surprise

amateur, bareback, anal, group, hardcore 2:00
Cream Pie Surprise

amateur, bareback, blowjobs, anal, group, hardcore 2:00
Screwing Tight Ass

anal, pov, hardcore 4:07
Surprise Gay Sucking

twinks, blowjobs, straight boys 4:07
Surprise Double Fuck

interracial, blowjobs, anal, hardcore, big cock 5:18
Latin Boys Pt. 4

twinks 1:23
Twink Double Fucked

twinks 1:31
Sexy Max (Solo)

big cock 2:00
Twink Double Fucked

twinks 1:24
Twink Double Fucked

bareback 2:25
Firefighter Jo

toys :52
Latin Boys Love It

bareback 2:26
Boyfriends Jesse and Austin fuck

twinks 5:02

Browse Our List

Gay Surprise Men - Page 2

Browse Our List

Our Good Friends